A RAC audit is a post-payment review of Medicare fee-for-service claims by a Recovery Audit Contractor (RAC), a private company the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) pays to find overpayments and underpayments. Medicare already paid the claim. The RAC checks whether it should have.
Most RAC audits start with a records request and a 45-day clock. A 30-day discussion window follows the findings. Once your Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) sends a demand letter, recoupment can begin on day 41. Miss one of those dates, and the RAC and your MAC move ahead without your side of the story.
Our team at One O Seven RCM builds ADR response packages and tracks RAC deadlines for practices and hospitals. The deadline practices can least afford to lose is the discussion period, since it’s the one chance to fix a finding before it turns into a demand letter.
This RAC audit guide covers the five regions, approved topics, ADR limits, the review steps, the discussion period, recoupment dates, appeals, and a 10-step checklist. If your letter came from a MAC, a UPIC, or a CERT reviewer, check the comparison table first, because each of those programs runs on its own clock.
| RAC Audit Key Facts for 2026Definition: a post-payment review of Medicare Part A and Part B fee-for-service claims under Social Security Act section 1893(h).Contractors: Performant (Regions 1 and 2) and Cotiviti GOV Services (Regions 3, 4, and 5, awarded April 28, 2025). Region 5 covers DMEPOS, home health, and hospice nationwide.Look-back: three years from the claim’s initial paid date, with no ADR until 60 days after that date.Records: 45 calendar days to respond (42 CFR 405.929), with facility limits starting at 0.5% of prior-year paid claims (1% for SNFs and IRFs).Discussion period: 30 days from the review results letter before the RAC sends the claim to your MAC.Recoupment and appeals: recoupment can start on day 41 after the MAC’s demand letter unless you file a redetermination by day 30, and appeals run five levels.Scale: RACs identified $486.64 million in overpayments in FY 2024 and recovered $382.21 million, while CMS CERT program data puts the FY 2025 Medicare fee-for-service improper payment rate at 6.55%, or $28.83 billion. |
Contractor, topic, and dollar figures checked against CMS on October 30, 2026.
What Is a RAC Audit?
A RAC audit is a review of Medicare fee-for-service claims that Medicare has already paid. Under CMS’s Medicare Fee-for-Service Recovery Audit Program, a recovery audit contractor checks each claim against coverage, coding, and payment rules, and reports overpayments and underpayments to your MAC for correction.
What Does RAC Stand For in Healthcare?
In medical billing, the RAC abbreviation stands for Recovery Audit Contractor, and CMS manuals also call each of these companies a Recovery Auditor. Their authority comes from Social Security Act section 1893, and Congress made the program permanent and nationwide through the Tax Relief and Health Care Act of 2006.
Outside healthcare, RAC can mean other things. On a letter about your Medicare claims, it means the Recovery Audit Contractor, and the letterhead will name the company that holds your region, either Performant or Cotiviti GOV Services.
What Is a Recovery Audit Contractor?
A Recovery Audit Contractor is a private company CMS hires to review claims in a set region. Section 1893(h) lets CMS pay recovery audit contractors on a contingent basis, so a RAC earns its fee from the improper payments it identifies and corrects.
If you appeal, the RAC’s payment waits too. Under CMS’s 2025 Statement of Work, a RAC doesn’t receive its contingency fee until the MAC and QIC appeal levels are complete, and it returns the fee if you win at any level. CMS first announced the appeal wait in its Recovery Audit Program improvements list.
RACs find underpayments too, and your MAC pays those back without a claim from you. Suspected fraud follows a different path. A RAC refers it instead of investigating it, because fraud investigations belong to Unified Program Integrity Contractors (UPICs).
Who Gets RAC Reviews?
Any provider or supplier that bills Medicare Part A or Part B fee-for-service can receive a Medicare RAC audit letter. In practice, that covers three groups:
- Hospitals, inpatient and outpatient, plus skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) and inpatient rehabilitation facilities (IRFs)
- Physicians, other professionals, and ambulatory surgical centers (ASCs)
- Home health agencies, hospices, and DMEPOS suppliers
RACs don’t review Medicare Advantage or Part D claims. The 2025 Statement of Work bars them from the Medicare Managed Care and Drug Benefit programs. Medicaid runs its own RAC programs through each state, and those follow separate rules.
Medicare RAC Contractors by Region in 2026
Two companies work as Medicare recovery audit contractors as of October 30, 2026. Performant covers Regions 1 and 2, and Cotiviti GOV Services covers Regions 3, 4, and 5. CMS awarded Cotiviti the Region 3 to 5 contracts on April 28, 2025, and Region 5 reviews DMEPOS, home health, and hospice claims nationwide.
The RAC audit regions below match the state lists CMS prints. Find your state, then save the email and phone number for your RAC before a letter arrives.
| Region | RAC | States and territories | Contact |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Performant | CT, IN, KY, MA, ME, MI, NH, NY, OH, RI, VT | info@Performantrac.com, 1-866-201-0580 |
| 2 | Performant | AR, CO, IA, IL, KS, LA, MO, MN, MS, NE, NM, OK, TX, WI | info@Performantrac.com, 1-866-201-0580 |
| 3 | Cotiviti GOV Services | AL, FL, GA, NC, SC, TN, VA, WV, Puerto Rico, US Virgin Islands | rac3info@cotiviti.com, 1-866-360-2507 |
| 4 | Cotiviti GOV Services | AK, AZ, CA, DC, DE, HI, ID, MD, MT, ND, NJ, NV, OR, PA, SD, UT, WA, WY, Guam, American Samoa, Northern Marianas | rac4info@cotiviti.com, 1-833-510-9689 |
| 5 | Cotiviti GOV Services | Nationwide: DMEPOS, home health, and hospice | rac5info@cotiviti.com, 1-833-510-9690 |
Source: CMS Recovery Audit Program page, last modified September 28, 2026. Confirm on CMS before relying on any table, including ours.
If you bill from Texas, you’re in Region 2, and your letters come from the Performant RAC. Practices in Florida, Georgia, or the Carolinas work with the Cotiviti RAC for Region 3 on all claims outside DMEPOS, home health, and hospice.
Which RAC to Contact After the Region 5 Change
Performant held Region 5 before the 2025 award, and it remains under contract with CMS for administrative and appeals work on the reviews it ran there. CMS tells providers to use the review completion date and the RAC name on the review results letter to decide which company to contact.
General questions for CMS go to RAC@cms.hhs.gov. Leave patient information out of that email, since CMS asks providers not to send protected health information to the address.
Where RAC Dollars Came From in FY 2024
In FY 2024, RACs identified $486.64 million in overpayments and $36.68 million in underpayments, and they recovered $382.21 million, according to CMS’s FY 2024 program integrity report. Region 3 identified the most. Across all regions, hospital outpatient reviews produced most of the collections.
| Region | Overpayments identified | Underpayments identified | Overpayments recovered |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $79.18M | $4.41M | $57.14M |
| 2 | $108.17M | $6.35M | $78.87M |
| 3 | $135.24M | $15.92M | $100.58M |
| 4 | $117.50M | $9.91M | $107.04M |
| 5 | $46.55M | $0.09M | $37.89M |
| Total | $486.64M | $36.68M | $382.21M |
The recovered total includes $8.70 million that CMS lists outside the five regions. CMS reports a 78.54% recovery rate for FY 2024.
RAC Audit Topics: What CMS Lets a RAC Review
A RAC can review only claims that fall under a topic CMS has approved and posted. CMS’s approved topics list showed 165 entries on October 30, 2026, and each entry names the review type, provider type, MAC jurisdictions, affected codes, and the policy rules the RAC will apply.
Outside that list, CMS RAC audits happen only as CMS-required reviews, which CMS orders after referrals from MACs, UPICs, the Office of Inspector General (OIG), or the Department of Justice (DOJ). The CMS approved RAC topics list states that these reviews sit outside the normal ADR limits.
A topic tells you which RAC audit risks apply to your codes. The rules inside it match what your MAC already enforces: national coverage determinations (NCDs), local coverage determinations, and CMS manuals.
How a Topic Gets Approved
Each topic a RAC proposes needs CMS review before the RAC pulls a single claim. CMS uses “approved issues” and “approved topics” for the same thing, so RAC approved issues and “RAC approval” both point to an entry on that list.
Once a topic receives conditional approval from CMS, the RAC has to post it on its website and wait 14 calendar days before starting reviews, under the 2025 Statement of Work. Those two weeks are your warning. Check your RAC’s site and the CMS list each month, the same habit you’d build for tracking MAC policy updates.
Approved Topics Worth Checking Now
These five entries from the CMS list hit service lines that hospitals and professional practices bill in high volume. The topic numbers and approval dates below match the CMS pages as of October 30, 2026.
| Topic | Review type | Provider type | Approved |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0001: Inpatient hospital MS-DRG coding validation | Complex | Inpatient hospital | 2017-02-01 |
| 0008: Bariatric surgery, medical necessity and documentation | Complex | Inpatient and outpatient hospital | 2017-02-01 |
| 0028: Annual Wellness Visit, excessive units | Automated | Professional services | 2017-03-29 |
| 0077: AWV billed sooner than 11 whole months after the IPPE (G0439, G0402) | Automated | Professional services | 2018-01-09 |
| 0176: AWV incorrect coding (G0402, G0438, G0439) | Complex | Professional services, all A/B MACs | 2025-08-28 |
Topic 0176 is a complex review, so a reviewer will read your Annual Wellness Visit (AWV) notes along with the claim dates. RAC topic 0176 on CMS lists the codes in scope, and our guide to G0438 AWV billing rules covers the documentation side.
Filter the CMS list by your provider type and MAC jurisdiction, then compare the affected codes with your top 20 billed codes. A match tells you which charts to test first, even if no ADR follows.
What Triggers a RAC Audit?
A RAC audit starts when your paid claims fall inside a CMS-approved topic and the RAC’s data analysis shows a likely error, such as units over a frequency limit. Under the 2025 Statement of Work, a RAC can’t pick claims at random for records requests, and it can’t target a claim only because it’s high dollar.
Six situations put a claim in front of a RAC reviewer:
- Your codes, provider type, MAC jurisdiction, and dates of service sit inside an approved topic.
- A data pattern flags the claim, such as excess units, frequency limits, duplicate lines, or DRG and diagnosis combinations.
- The record doesn’t support the service, or a required order or signature is missing.
- Your RAC denial rate runs high, which raises your ADR limit for the next three cycles.
- CMS orders the review after a referral from a MAC, UPIC, OIG, or DOJ, outside the normal ADR limits.
- National error data points at your service line, since CERT and OIG findings help shape the topics CMS approves.
Documentation carries the largest share of the risk. Insufficient documentation made up 53.0% of Medicare fee-for-service improper payments in FY 2025, according to CMS’s FY 2025 supplemental improper payment data. The same missing pieces tend to show up first as CO-50 medical necessity denials on your remits.
What a RAC Isn’t Allowed to Do
The RAC Statement of Work dated April 28, 2025, sets firm limits on how a RAC selects and reviews claims. If a letter crosses one of these lines, you’ve got an argument for your discussion request or your appeal.
| A RAC can’t | Source |
|---|---|
| Use clinical validation in any review | 2025 SOW |
| Propose or run reviews based on NCCI edits | 2025 SOW |
| Do onsite visits to review records | 2025 SOW |
| Use random selection to choose claims for records requests | 2025 SOW |
| Target a claim only because it’s a high-dollar claim | 2025 SOW |
| Attempt recoupment on overpayments under $25, except extrapolated claims | 2025 SOW |
| Review Medicare Advantage or Part D claims | 2025 SOW |
| Review a claim another contractor already reviewed, an exclusion that doesn’t expire | 2025 SOW |
| Send an ADR sooner than 60 days after the claim’s paid date | 2025 SOW |
If several of your top codes sit inside an approved topic, it’s worth testing those charts before a RAC does. A RAC readiness audit from our team checks a sample of those claims against the topic rules and shows where the notes fall short.
Automated vs Complex RAC Reviews
RAC audits come in two types. An automated review checks claim data alone and needs no medical records, while a complex review means a clinician or certified coder reads your records after an Additional Documentation Request (ADR). CMS’s program page describes these two review types and no others.
| Feature | Automated review | Complex review |
|---|---|---|
| Records needed | No | Yes, through an ADR |
| Who decides | System logic applied to claim data | Clinicians and certified coders, with a Contractor Medical Director available |
| Typical findings | Excess units, frequency limits, duplicates, and services billed during an inpatient stay | Medical necessity, DRG validation, and documentation support |
| When you hear back | No later than 7 business days after the RAC finds the error | Within 30 calendar days of the RAC receiving your records |
| What you receive | A review results letter | An ADR first, then a review results letter |
Source: 2025 RAC Statement of Work and the CMS Recovery Audit Program page.
A RAC automated review often turns on one date or one edit, such as a second AWV billed before 11 full months have passed since the last one. Check the dates and the policy version the RAC applied. You can still request a discussion on an automated finding.
A RAC complex review puts your documentation on the table. Some older guides list a third, semi-automated type. CMS’s current program page names two, so treat any request for records as a complex review with a 45-day clock.
How Far Back Can a RAC Audit Go?
A RAC audit can reach back three years from the claim’s initial paid date, under CMS’s 2025 Statement of Work. For complex reviews, the RAC measures those three years to the date of the ADR. Automated reviews count to the date of the review results letter.
The RAC look-back period has a floor as well: the RAC has to wait at least 60 calendar days after the paid date before sending an ADR, which gives your MAC time to log its own reviews first. A claim another contractor already reviewed stays excluded from RAC review for good.
Some guides say the three years run from the date of service. The SOW counts from the paid date, which can stretch the window by weeks or months on a claim that paid late after a rejection or a hold.
MACs, UPICs, and CERT reviewers follow Medicare’s general reopening rules, and those run on different clocks. Don’t apply the RAC’s three-year window to a letter from another contractor. Check which contractor signed the letter first, then count your dates.
RAC ADR Limits: How Many Records a RAC Can Request
CMS caps how many records a RAC can request through an additional documentation request. A hospital or other facility starts with a yearly limit of 0.5% of its Medicare paid claims from the prior 12 months, or 1% for SNFs and IRFs, and CMS splits that number across eight 45-day cycles.
ADR Limits for Hospitals and Other Facilities
CMS counts paid claims by CMS Certification Number (CCN) and NPI, and it divides the limit by type of bill, so one service line can’t absorb every request.
Divide the yearly limit by eight to get the limit per 45-day cycle. Fractions below .5 round down, and .5 or higher rounds up. If the cycle figure falls below one while the yearly limit sits above one, the cycle limit becomes one until you’ve used the yearly total.
Take a hospital with 12,000 paid Medicare claims last year. Its yearly limit is 60, which is 0.5% of 12,000. Divide by eight and you get 7.5, and that rounds up to eight records per 45-day cycle. The rounding rules come from the CMS institutional ADR limits document.
How Your Denial Rate Raises or Lowers the Limit
After three cycles, CMS calculates your denial rate: claims with overpayments, minus claims fully overturned on appeal, divided by claims reviewed, using the latest 12 months of completed reviews. Your adjusted limit applies for the next three cycles, and then CMS runs the numbers again.
Reversals you win in the discussion period or through a clerical reopening don’t count as overturns in that formula. A discussion win helps your cash flow, and an appeal win is the one that lowers the denial rate CMS uses for your next limit.
| Denial rate | Multiplier | Yearly limit for standard facilities |
|---|---|---|
| 91% to 100% | 10x | 5.0% of paid claims |
| 71% to 90% | 8x | 4.0% of paid claims |
| 51% to 70% | 6x | 3.0% of paid claims |
| 36% to 50% | 3x | 1.5% of paid claims |
| 21% to 35% | 2x | 1.0% of paid claims |
| 10% to 20% | 1x | 0.5% of paid claims |
| 4% to 9% | 0.5x | 0.25% of paid claims |
| 0% to 3% | None | No reviews for the next three cycles |
SNFs and IRFs use the same multipliers on their 1% baseline. Run the same hospital again at a 40% denial rate, and the limit moves to 1.5%, or 180 records a year. That’s 22.5 per cycle, which rounds up to 23 records every 45 days.
ADR Limits for Physicians and DME Suppliers
Physician and other professional limits apply per Tax Identification Number (TIN) plus the first three digits of the practice ZIP code. The count depends on how many rendering practitioners bill under that combination, per the CMS physician ADR limits document.
| Rendering practitioners | Records per 45 days |
|---|---|
| 50 or more | 50 |
| 25 to 49 | 40 |
| 6 to 24 | 25 |
| Fewer than 5 | 10 |
CMS’s own example in that document applies the 10-record limit to a group of six practitioners, so confirm your number with your RAC before you argue a count. CMS can also approve a higher limit for a RAC, and CMS-required reviews sit outside these limits.
DMEPOS suppliers face a limit of 10% of paid claims per HCPCS policy group per TIN, split across eight 45-day cycles and capped at 250 records per 45 days. Orthotic and prosthetic items from specialty codes 51, 52, 53, 55, 56, and 57 cap at 10 per 45 days, per the CMS supplier ADR limits.
Twenty-three packets every 45 days is a second job for a small billing team. If your limit climbed after the last recalculation, our RAC defense support can build the packets and track each cycle with you.
The RAC Audit Process, Step by Step
The recovery audit process runs in eight steps. CMS approves a topic, the RAC selects claims and sends a letter, you send records within 45 days, and the RAC reviews them and issues a review results letter. A 30-day discussion period follows, and then your MAC adjusts the claim and sends any demand letter.
- Topic posted. CMS approves the topic, and the RAC posts it and waits 14 days.
- Claims selected. The RAC picks paid claims at least 60 days and no more than three years past the paid date.
- Letter sent. You get an ADR for a complex review or a review results letter for an automated one.
- Records due in 45 calendar days. Under 42 CFR 405.929, the contractor accepts late records only for good cause, and the RAC denies a claim with no response. That’s how CO-226 no-response denials end up on remits.
- RAC review. The RAC reads the records and owes you results within 30 days of receiving them.
- Review results letter. Each claim comes back as no finding, an overpayment, or an underpayment, with the reason and the policy cited.
- Discussion period. The RAC holds the claim for 30 days so you can send more information or talk with its reviewers.
- MAC adjustment. Your MAC adjusts the claim, and any demand letter starts your appeal and recoupment clocks.
How Long Does a RAC Audit Take?
If each window runs to its limit, a complex review takes about 105 days from the ADR to the RAC’s handoff to your MAC: 45 days for records, 30 for the RAC’s decision, and 30 for discussion. Treat that RAC audit timeline as the outer bound, before your MAC’s own processing time.
| Milestone | Clock |
|---|---|
| ADR date | Day 0 |
| Records due | Day 45, in calendar days |
| RAC decision | Within 30 days of receiving your records |
| Discussion period | 30 days from the review results letter |
| MAC demand letter | After the RAC forwards the claim |
| Redetermination to block recoupment | By day 30 after the demand letter |
| Earliest recoupment | Day 41 after the demand letter |
How to Answer a RAC Additional Documentation Request
You have 45 calendar days from the date on a RAC ADR to send the records it lists, under 42 CFR 405.929. Before anyone pulls a chart, check four things the RAC has to get right: the topic, the dates, the claim’s review history, and your ADR limit. Then confirm your own mailing details.
- Topic match. Look up the topic number from the letter on the CMS approved list, and confirm it covers your codes, provider type, and MAC jurisdiction.
- Date window. Confirm the claim paid at least 60 days and no more than three years before the ADR date.
- Review history. If another contractor already reviewed the claim, tell the RAC in writing and identify the earlier review.
- ADR count. Compare the number of claims requested with your limit for this 45-day cycle, unless CMS required the review.
- Mailing addresses. Confirm the addresses on your Medicare enrollment record in PECOS are current, so review letters reach the right desk.
If a check fails, tell the RAC in writing before the 45 days run out, and send the records anyway. A RAC audit doesn’t pause because you disagree with it, and an unanswered request ends in a denial no matter how strong your argument was.
Send records through the RAC’s provider portal or esMD where you can, since both give you a timestamp. Keep an exact copy of each page you sent. You’ll need the same set for the discussion period and any appeal that follows.
The RAC Discussion Period: Your 30-Day Window Before the MAC
The RAC discussion period is a 30-day window after the review results letter when you can send new information or talk with the RAC before it forwards the claim to your MAC. Under CMS’s 2025 Statement of Work, the RAC waits 30 calendar days before sending the claim for adjustment.
Request discussion in writing, through the RAC’s portal or by the method printed on the results letter. The RAC has to confirm a written request within one business day and send its decision within 30 calendar days of finishing the discussion, according to the SOW.
A physician can also ask for a peer-to-peer call with the RAC’s Contractor Medical Director (CMD). The SOW says that physician should be one who treated the patient or who works for the provider at the same facility. Consultants and billing administrators aren’t appropriate for the call, though coders and other clinicians can join depending on the review type.
A useful discussion packet holds four things:
- Missing pages the reviewer didn’t have, such as orders, signed notes, or test results
- The exact policy language the claim meets, quoted from the LCD, NCD, or manual
- Any SOW limit the review crossed, taken from the table of what a RAC can’t do
- A cover summary that ties each finding to the page that answers it
You don’t have to choose between discussion and appeal. CMS built the 30-day hold so providers can use both, as its Recovery Audit Program improvements list explains. The discussion period doesn’t pause or extend your 120-day redetermination window either, because that clock starts with the MAC’s notice.
Route review results letters to the same person who owns your RAC deadlines. A results letter that sits in a general mail pile for three weeks leaves you about nine days to build a discussion packet.
RAC Audit Results, the Demand Letter, and Recoupment
RAC audit results arrive in a review results letter that marks each claim as no finding, an overpayment, or an underpayment. After the 30-day discussion period, the RAC sends its findings to your MAC, which adjusts the claim and sends any demand letter. That letter starts your appeal and recoupment clocks.
What Happens When a RAC Finds an Overpayment
The RAC doesn’t bill you. Your MAC does. The RAC demand letter people search for is a MAC demand letter that follows a RAC finding, and its date starts each deadline in the table below. Underpayments run the other way, with your MAC adjusting the claim and paying you.
| Day after the demand letter | What happens |
|---|---|
| 15 | Last day for a rebuttal, which doesn’t stop recoupment |
| 30 | Pay in full, or file a redetermination to keep recoupment from starting on day 41 |
| 31 | Interest starts on the unpaid balance, appeal or not |
| 41 | Recoupment starts if you haven’t paid or appealed |
| 120 | Last day to file a redetermination |
Source: CMS Medicare overpayments fact sheet (MLN006379, July 2025).
Filing after day 30 still helps, but less. If you file between day 31 and day 120, the MAC stops recoupment once it receives and validates your appeal. The MAC won’t refund amounts it already recouped until it decides the redetermination.
If the redetermination goes against you, recoupment can resume on the 60th day after that decision unless you file for reconsideration, under 42 CFR 405.379. Can’t pay in one lump sum? Ask for an Extended Repayment Schedule using the instructions in the demand letter.
The 30-day mark is easy to miss when a demand letter lands during the end-of-month close. Our denial and appeal management team can log each demand date and file the redetermination before day 30.
RAC Audit Appeal: How to Challenge a RAC Determination
You appeal a Medicare RAC audit finding through the same five levels as any Medicare overpayment, starting with a redetermination filed with your MAC within 120 days of receiving the notice. The RAC doesn’t decide any level of the appeal, though it supports the case file along the way.
| Level | Who decides | File within | Decision target | Minimum in dispute, 2026 | From January 1, 2027 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Redetermination | Your MAC | 120 days | 60 days | None | None |
| 2. Reconsideration | Qualified Independent Contractor (QIC) | 180 days | 60 days | None | None |
| 3. Hearing | Administrative Law Judge (ALJ), OMHA | 60 days | 90 days | $200 | $200 |
| 4. Review | Medicare Appeals Council | 60 days | 90 days | None | None |
| 5. Judicial review | Federal district court | 60 days | No set limit | $1,960 | $2,000 |
Sources: CMS Medicare appeals booklet (MLN006562), the 2026 appeal thresholds notice, and the 2027 appeal thresholds notice. CMS presumes you received a notice five days after its date.
Put your full evidence in by Level 2. Under MLN006562, an ALJ considers evidence you held back past the QIC level only if you show good cause, and that’s a hard standard to meet after the fact.
Recoupment stays paused through Levels 1 and 2 when you file on time. Under 42 CFR 405.379, it stays in effect if you go on to the ALJ, the Council, or federal court, so plan your cash flow before you escalate.
ALJ wait times have dropped. OMHA reports an average processing time of 69 days for FY 2026, down from 1,430 days in FY 2020, on its OMHA processing times page.
When a RAC Audit Attorney Makes Sense
Bring in a healthcare attorney for an extrapolated demand, a large amount in dispute, an ALJ hearing, or any sign of a fraud referral. One O Seven RCM is a revenue cycle company and doesn’t give legal advice. Our appeals team builds the claim file and timeline and works alongside your counsel.
Can a RAC Use Extrapolation?
Yes, a RAC can use extrapolation, with CMS approval and only where the law allows it. Under Social Security Act section 1893(f)(3), a Medicare contractor can extrapolate only if there’s a sustained or high level of payment error, or if documented educational intervention failed to correct the error.
The 2025 SOW requires approval from CMS’s RAC contracting officer’s representative before a RAC extrapolates. It also requires the RAC to follow the sampling rules in Program Integrity Manual Chapter 8, section 8.4.
Extrapolation projects the error rate from a sample across the whole group of similar claims, which is how a sample of 30 charts can turn into a six-figure demand. You can’t appeal CMS’s finding of a sustained or high error level, but you can challenge the sample and the math, so request the sampling file early.
Some 2026 articles say extrapolation is paused. That reporting concerns litigation over Medicare risk adjustment audit (RADV) rules for Medicare Advantage plans, and it doesn’t change how RACs review fee-for-service claims.
RAC vs MAC, UPIC, TPE, and CERT
Recovery audit contractors look for improper payments on claims Medicare already paid, within CMS-approved topics, and they earn a contingency fee. A MAC processes your claims and runs its own medical review, a UPIC investigates fraud, TPE is your MAC’s review and education program, and CERT samples claims to measure the national error rate.
| Program | Purpose | Records due | How far back | How it’s paid | Can it suspend payments? | Worst likely outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RAC | Improper payments on paid claims, approved topics only | 45 days | 3 years from paid date | Contingency fee from recoveries | No | MAC demand letter and a higher ADR limit |
| MAC medical review | Coverage, coding, and documentation, before or after payment | 45 days | Medicare reopening rules | Standard CMS contract | Only with CMS approval | Denials and a demand letter |
| TPE (run by your MAC) | Review and education, 20 to 40 claims per round, up to 3 rounds | 45 days | Claims picked each round | Standard CMS contract | No | Referral to CMS after 3 rounds |
| UPIC | Fraud, waste, and abuse investigations | 30 days | Any time for fraud or similar fault | Standard CMS contract | Only with CMS approval | Suspension, or referral to OIG or law enforcement |
| CERT | Random sample to measure the national improper payment rate | 45 days on the request letter | One reporting year | Standard CMS contract | No | Claim counted as an error and adjusted |
The SOW excludes any claim another contractor already reviewed, which answers most RAC vs UPIC questions about the same claim. If a UPIC or your MAC already reviewed it, say so in writing when the RAC asks.
A failed TPE cycle is a separate route into a RAC review. CMS’s Targeted Probe and Educate page lists referral to a Recovery Auditor among the possible actions after three rounds of education that don’t fix the errors, along with 100% prepayment review and extrapolation.
RAC Risk by Provider Type
RAC risk depends on what you bill. Hospital outpatient reviews produced most RAC collections in FY 2024, according to CMS’s program integrity report, and DMEPOS claims carried the highest FY 2025 improper payment rate of the four claim types on CMS’s CERT page, at 24.12%.
Hospitals, Inpatient and Outpatient
Hospitals face RAC audits on both sides of the house. Topic 0001, MS-DRG coding validation, is a complex review of inpatient claims, and facility ADR limits split by type of bill, so inpatient and outpatient work each carry their own count.
CMS CERT data puts the FY 2025 improper payment rate at 3.15% ($4.61 billion) for hospital IPPS claims and 6.67% ($13.20 billion) for Part A providers outside IPPS. Our hospital revenue cycle management team reviews DRG assignment and clinical documentation before claims go out, and our guide to inpatient vs outpatient coding covers where the coding rules split.
Skilled Nursing and Inpatient Rehab Facilities
SNFs and IRFs start at double the facility ADR baseline, 1% of paid claims instead of 0.5%. CMS’s FY 2025 supplemental improper payment data puts the SNF improper payment rate at 11.8%, or $4.3 billion, for the 2025 report period.
Physicians who see patients during a SNF stay bill their visits apart from the facility claim, and those visit codes need their own documentation. Our guide to SNF professional billing codes covers the codes and the notes behind them.
RAC Audits for Home Health, Hospice, and DME
Region 5 reviews DMEPOS, home health, and hospice claims nationwide, and Cotiviti GOV Services has held it since the April 28, 2025, award. CMS CERT data puts the FY 2025 DMEPOS improper payment rate at 24.12%, or $2.27 billion.
Suppliers work under the 10% ADR formula by HCPCS policy group, capped at 250 records per 45 days. If your agency or supply company bills Medicare in volume, our home health and DME billing team handles claims and documentation follow-up for both.
Physician and Professional Practices
Part B providers ran an 8.44% improper payment rate in FY 2025, or $9.62 billion, per CMS CERT data. Professional topics on the CMS list include 0043 (new patient visits, incorrect coding), 0042 (office visit codes billed for hospital inpatients), and the AWV topics 0028, 0077, and 0176.
Small practices still get picked. A RAC audit of a practice with fewer than five rendering practitioners can pull 10 charts every 45 days, and that’s a heavy load for a front desk that also runs check-in and phones.
Medicaid Recovery Audit Contractors
A Medicaid recovery audit contractor works for your state Medicaid agency instead of CMS. Section 6411 of the Affordable Care Act required states to set up Medicaid RAC programs, and CMS’s Medicaid RAC final rule of September 16, 2011, set the framework at 42 CFR part 455, subpart F.
Each state sets its own look-back, records limits, and appeal route, and states can request exceptions from the program, so a Medicare RAC’s rules don’t carry over. Check your state Medicaid agency’s RAC page before you answer a Medicaid request.
Senator Rick Scott introduced the Medicaid RAC Improvement Act of 2026 (S. 4898) on June 24, 2026. The bill would add federal oversight and reporting for state programs and require states to include managed care plans in their recovery audits.
RAC Audit Checklist: 10 Steps Before the Next ADR
A RAC audit checklist comes down to knowing your RAC, your topics, your limits, and your deadlines before a letter arrives. The 10 steps below take an afternoon or so to set up, plus a short monthly check after that.
- Find your region and RAC on the CMS table, and save its portal, email, and phone number.
- Name one owner and a backup for RAC mail and the RAC portal.
- Check the CMS approved topics list each month against your top 20 billed codes.
- Calculate your ADR limit with the facility, physician, or supplier formula, so you know what a normal request looks like.
- Track your RAC denial rate, since it sets your limit for the next three cycles.
- Sample charts under your active topics each quarter, scored by someone who didn’t code them.
- Keep one deadline log for each RAC audit: 45 days for records, 30 for discussion, and 30 and 120 days after the demand.
- Confirm the addresses on your PECOS enrollment record, since review letters go there.
- Decide in advance when you’ll request discussion and when you’ll go straight to appeal.
- Log each underpayment a RAC finds, and confirm the MAC paid it.
Step 6 is the one teams put off, since scoring charts takes time few teams have in a normal week. A mock RAC review from our audit team samples claims under your active topics and shows what a RAC reviewer would deny.
What Changed for RACs in 2025 and 2026
The biggest change to RAC audits in 2025 and 2026 was a new contractor for three of the five regions, after CMS awarded Cotiviti GOV Services the Region 3, 4, and 5 contracts on April 28, 2025. CMS also approved a complex AWV coding topic and published new appeal thresholds for 2026 and 2027.
- April 28, 2025: CMS awarded Regions 3, 4, and 5 to Cotiviti GOV Services, posted the update on May 14, 2025, and expected reviews to begin that summer.
- August 28, 2025: CMS approved topic 0176, AWV incorrect coding, as a complex review across all A/B MACs.
- January 1, 2026: the ALJ minimum became $200, and the federal court minimum became $1,960.
- June 24, 2026: Senator Rick Scott introduced the Medicaid RAC Improvement Act of 2026 (S. 4898).
- FY 2026: OMHA reported an average ALJ processing time of 69 days.
- September 16, 2026: a Federal Register notice set the 2027 federal court minimum at $2,000 and kept the ALJ minimum at $200, effective January 1, 2027.
- September 28, 2026: CMS updated its Recovery Audit Program page.
RAC Audit Questions Providers Ask
Is a RAC audit a fraud investigation?
No. A RAC audit looks for payment errors on claims Medicare already paid, such as coding mistakes, missing documentation, or services that didn’t meet coverage rules. RACs refer suspected fraud instead of investigating it, since fraud cases belong to UPICs. A RAC letter still needs a fast response, because an unanswered request ends in a denial.
What should you not say during a RAC discussion or peer-to-peer call?
Don’t guess, and don’t add facts the record doesn’t support. If the reviewer asks something the chart doesn’t answer, say you’ll check and follow up in writing. Don’t promise to fix a note, since late entries have to be dated and labeled as additions. Keep the call on the policy the claim meets and the pages that prove it.
What does RAC approval mean?
RAC approval means CMS has approved a review topic that RACs can audit. Each approved topic on CMS’s list names the review type, provider type, MAC jurisdictions, and affected codes. A RAC has to post a topic with conditional approval on its website and wait 14 days before starting reviews. Outside approved topics, RACs review claims only on CMS’s order.
Can a RAC and a MAC review the same claim?
Not as a second review. Under CMS’s 2025 Statement of Work, a claim another entity already reviewed is excluded from RAC review, and the exclusion doesn’t expire. RACs also wait 60 days after the paid date before an ADR, which gives MACs time to log their reviews. If a RAC asks about one of those claims, tell it in writing.
Can a RAC find money Medicare owes you?
Yes. RACs report underpayments as well as overpayments. In FY 2024, RACs identified $36.68 million in underpayments, according to CMS’s program integrity report. Your MAC adjusts the claim and pays the difference, so you don’t file anything. Track each one in your deadline log anyway and confirm the payment posted, since RACs don’t forward underpayments under $5 to the MAC.
Do RACs review Medicare Advantage claims?
No. RACs review Medicare fee-for-service claims under Parts A and B, including DMEPOS, home health, and hospice. CMS’s Statement of Work bars RACs from Medicare Advantage and Part D claims. A Medicare Advantage plan can still audit you under your contract with that plan, so check who sent a letter before you treat it as a RAC audit letter.
Get Ahead of Your Next RAC Letter
A RAC audit goes smoother when your team already knows its region, its topics, and its deadlines. Set up the checklist once, and the next letter becomes a routine task on your calendar instead of a scramble across three inboxes.
If you’d rather hand off the billing side, our full-service medical billing covers coding, claims, denials, and appeals, starting at 3% of collections. Talk to the One O Seven RCM team about what’s in your next RAC request.