Email Call Message
THIS THANKSGIVING, PAY LESS FOR MEDICAL BILLING! Get Expert Medical Billing Services at Just 2.39% Switch to One O Seven RCM & Start Saving Today! | Terms Apply.
THIS THANKSGIVING, PAY LESS FOR MEDICAL BILLING! Get Expert Medical Billing Services at Just 2.39% Switch to One O Seven RCM & Start Saving Today! | Terms Apply.

Therapy Claims Underpaid? Why Practices Lose Revenue on 90837 and Similar Codes

Therapy Claims Underpaid? Why Practices Lose 90837 Revenue, therapist marking a short payment on a remittance

Therapy claims underpaid by a few dollars a line don’t set off an alarm. Your ERA, the electronic remittance advice, marks each one as paid. The payer books the shortfall as an adjustment, and nobody on your team gets a denial to work.

Most therapy claims are underpaid for one of six reasons: the payer downcoded 90837 to 90834, the note didn’t show 53 minutes of psychotherapy, the payer used the wrong fee schedule or provider tier, a telehealth place of service or modifier triggered a lower rate, the practice missed an add-on code, or an out-of-network repricer cut the allowed amount.

Medicare makes the dollar gap easy to see. On CY2026 national non-facility rates, 90837 pays $167.00 and 90834 pays $113.90, so every 90837 paid as a 90834 costs you $53.10. Commercial gaps depend on each contract, and either way, it’s mental health practice revenue loss that never appears on a denial report.

Key takeaways90837 needs 53 or more documented minutes of psychotherapy.Each 90837 paid as a 90834 loses $53.10 on CY2026 Medicare rates.A 90837 underpaid by the payer still posts as paid, with the shortfall inside CO-45.Sequestration, deductibles, and coinsurance don’t count as underpayments.Medicare gives you 120 days to request a redetermination.

Rates and rules current as of November 2026, including the CY2027 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule final rule.

What Counts as an Underpaid Therapy Claim?

A therapy claim is underpaid when the payer pays it but allows less than the rate in your contract or the published fee schedule. The code is right and the patient was eligible, yet the payer sent less than it agreed to pay.

A therapy claim underpayment stays invisible because the ERA shows the line as paid. Your posting team moves the balance into a contractual adjustment, the claim drops off the aging report, and no one gets a task to work it.

Take a 90837 billed at $200 with a contracted rate of $140. The payer allows $120, so the ERA shows an $80 CO-45 adjustment where the contract supports $60. That $20 gap is the underpayment, and most billers skim past it.

The CO-45 adjustment code tells you the charge exceeded the fee schedule, maximum allowable, or contracted rate. It can’t tell you whether the payer used the right contracted rate. If an insurer underpays a therapist, the shortfall sits inside that one line, and you’ll catch it by comparing contracted rate versus paid amount.

What happenedWhat the ERA showsIs money still owed?Usual fix
Denied$0 paid, with a CARC on the lineMaybe, if the denial is wrongCorrect and resubmit, or appeal
Downcoded by the payerPaid as a lower code, such as 90834 for a billed 90837Yes, if the note supports the billed codeAppeal with time documentation
UnderpaidRight code, allowed amount below contractYesPayment dispute with the fee schedule attached
Reduced for a valid reasonDeductible, coinsurance, or sequestrationNoBill the patient or write it off

Getting that money back is AR work: someone has to dispute the line against the contract, which is what underpaid claims recovery covers. Before that, put a dollar figure on the gap so you know which payers to chase first.

How Much an Underpaid 90837 Costs Your Practice in 2026 and 2027

On CY2026 Medicare national non-facility rates, every 90837 paid at the 90834 rate loses $53.10. Medicare pays clinical social workers, marriage and family therapists, and mental health counselors 75% of those amounts, so the same mistake costs them about $39.82 per session.

CPT codePsychotherapy timeCY2026 Medicare amount75% amount (CSW, MFT, MHC)
9083216 to 37 minutes$85.84$64.38
9083438 to 52 minutes$113.90$85.43
9083753 minutes or more$167.00$125.25

CY2026 Medicare national amounts, non-facility, before locality adjustment. The 90837 facility amount is $135.27.

Put that on a calendar. One qualifying session a day paid or billed as 90834, five days a week for 48 weeks, adds up to 240 sessions. At the full rate, that’s 240 × $53.10 = $12,744 per clinician per year. The 75% rate brings it to about $9,558.

Those figures are arithmetic on published Medicare rates, and they aren’t an industry benchmark. No one has published a national psychotherapy underpayment rate. Underpaid therapy claims on commercial plans can cost more or less than this, so run the same math on your own fee schedules.

Your locality rate will differ from the national number, and you can pull it for any code in the CMS Physician Fee Schedule Look-Up Tool. For the full coding rules behind each threshold, see our CPT 90837 billing guide.

CMS finalized the 2027 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule on November 4, 2026, effective January 1, 2027. The conversion factor for most clinicians drops 2.31%, from $33.40 to $32.63.

Psychotherapy codes also get the last step of an increase in work values that CMS phased in over four years starting in 2024. Check the 2027 amounts for 90832, 90834, and 90837 in the look-up tool before you update your expected-payment table in January.

Why Therapy Claims Get Underpaid: Causes Inside Your Practice

Some short payments start before the claim leaves your office. You can fix the three causes below this month, and no payer will point them out, since your team either never bills them or bills them at a level the note can’t defend.

Billing 90834 When the Session Met 90837

A session with 53 or more documented minutes of psychotherapy qualifies for 90837. If your clinician bills it as 90834, the payer pays the lower code and moves on. Payers don’t correct a practice’s own undercoding, so that difference stays lost until someone on your team catches it.

You’ll see this with clinicians who run 55-minute sessions and bill 90834 out of habit, or because a colleague warned them that 90837 draws audits. A 50-minute block on the scheduling template makes it worse, since the calendar and the note end up telling different stories.

Pull a month of 90834 claims and compare them with the note times. If a note supports 53 minutes or more, many payers accept a corrected claim inside their filing window, so check each payer’s rules before you resubmit. Our guide to 90834 vs 90837 time rules lays out each threshold.

Time Documentation a Reviewer Can’t Verify

A 90837 holds up on review when the note shows the psychotherapy time, and start and stop times work best. Without that, a payer can downcode the claim on review or recoup the payment months later, and a paid claim turns into a 90837 recoupment.

Reviewers treat three documentation patterns as unsupported or automated:

  • No psychotherapy time recorded in the note
  • A template that prints “60 minutes” on every session
  • Note times that don’t match the scheduling record

Prescribers face one more trap. Time spent on the E/M portion of a visit can’t count toward psychotherapy time, and psychotherapy minutes can’t count toward the E/M. Your note needs both times, each on its own line, or the add-on code has nothing to stand on.

Medicare auditors have looked hard at this. The HHS OIG psychotherapy audit found that Medicare paid $1 billion for psychotherapy from March 2020 through February 2021 and estimated $580 million of it was improper. Providers met Medicare requirements on 84 of 216 sampled days, and missing psychotherapy time was a recurring finding.

A template problem doesn’t stay with one claim. If a 90837 audit finds the same “60 minutes” line on every note, the payer can apply the finding to every claim that template touched and demand the money back as a therapy insurance clawback. Thin medical necessity language causes a similar pattern with CO-50 medical necessity denials.

Missed Add-Ons and Same-Day Pairing Errors

Add-on codes get missed because they never trigger a denial. Nobody bills them, so nothing comes back. Pairing errors cause the opposite problem: the practice bills two codes that can’t go together, and the payer denies or bundles one of them.

The 90785 interactive complexity add-on applies when a specific communication factor complicates the session, such as a caregiver whose behavior interferes or the need for an interpreter. Your note has to name that factor. If 90785 is not paid, check the note first, since CMS contractor guidance also bars 90785 when the patient can’t communicate by any means.

ScenarioCommon errorCorrect billingRevenue effect
Interpreter, caregiver interference, or another qualifying factor90785 never billed90785 with the psychotherapy code, with the factor documentedRevenue never billed
Crisis sessionBilled as routine psychotherapy90839 for the first 60 minutes, plus 90840 for each additional 30 minutes; not reported with 90832 to 90838 or 90785Lower payment or a denied line
Prescriber visit with medication management and therapy99214 plus a standalone 90837E/M code plus 90833, 90836, or 90838 by psychotherapy time; some payers also want modifier 25 on the E/MDenied psychotherapy line
Intake and therapy on the same day90791 and 90837 by the same clinicianBill one service; CPT bars psychotherapy codes on the same day as 90791Denied line

That last row is a common reason a 90791 is denied on an intake day. CPT guidance for 90791 says psychotherapy services, including crisis, may not be reported on the same day, so 90791 and 90837 on the same day by the same clinician won’t both pay.

For 90839 crisis billing, CPT also bars 90785, since crisis care already accounts for the communication burden. On prescriber visits, 90838 billing requires 53 or more minutes of psychotherapy that sit outside the E/M time. Once your coding and notes are clean, any shortfall that remains points to the payer.

Why Therapy Claims Get Underpaid: Causes on the Payer Side

Mental health claims underpaid after clean coding tend to trace back to how the payer priced the line. Five patterns show up again and again on therapy remits, and you can spot each one once you know which column of the ERA to check.

Silent Downcoding of 90837 to 90834

Silent downcoding means the payer pays a billed 90837 at the 90834 rate without denying it, and often without asking for records. The one way to catch a 90837 paid as a 90834 is to compare the paid code or allowed amount against what you billed.

On the ERA, the line shows a lower allowed amount, sometimes with CARC 150. That code means the payer decided the information submitted doesn’t support the level of service billed. A 90837 underpaid this way looks like a normal payment unless your posting team checks the code on every line.

Physician groups have pushed back. In November 2026, the AMA House of Delegates strengthened its AMA policy on payer downcoding, which describes programs that cut the reported level of service with algorithms and no review of the medical record. Our guide to how payer downcoding works covers the mechanics across specialties.

States have started to act on insurance downcoding of therapy sessions and other claims. Indiana’s House Enrolled Act 1271, in effect since July 1, 2026, bars insurers from using AI as the sole basis for downcoding without human review, though its downcoding chapter excludes Medicaid managed care.

Lawmakers in California, Connecticut, Illinois, Maryland, Missouri, and Oregon introduced downcoding bills in 2026. Still, no one has published data on how often psychotherapy downcoding by insurance happens, so your own remits are the best measure. Count how many billed 90837 lines paid as 90834 last quarter.

The Wrong Fee Schedule or an Outdated Contract Rate

A claim can carry the right code and still pay short because the payer’s system loaded an old rate, a different product’s fee schedule, or a rate change you never agreed to. If a therapist is paid less than the fee schedule in the contract, start by checking how the payer loaded it.

Contract amendments cause most of these errors. Say a payer agrees to a new rate in March, but its claims system keeps pricing at the old rate into the summer. Platform and network contracts add another layer, because a payer’s rate change applies to every clinician billing under that agreement.

The 2026 Aetna episode shows how fast this moves. On May 20, 2026, clinicians contracted through the Alma platform got notice that Aetna would pay 90837 at the same rate as 90834, along with other reductions.

The American Psychiatric Association and APA Services objected in an APA letter to Aetna. On July 8, Alma told clinicians that Aetna had dropped the plan to merge the two rates, though Alma said the final rates still cut overall reimbursement for mental health services.

Keep a copy of every fee schedule and amendment you sign, with the effective date. Then check the first remits after each effective date, because that’s when a loading error first appears on your ERA.

Credential Tier, Taxonomy, and Rendering Provider Errors

Payers price therapy by who rendered it. Medicare pays clinical social workers, marriage and family therapists, and mental health counselors 75% of the clinical psychologist rate, per the CMS rules for MFTs and counselors and 42 CFR 414.53. That 75 percent Medicare rate for an LCSW explains why LCSW reimbursement runs lower than a psychologist’s for the same 90837.

Taxonomy errors push claims into the wrong tier. Picture an associate whose claims go out under the group NPI with a taxonomy code the payer doesn’t recognize for that clinician. The payer may price the line at a lower tier or treat it as out of network, and the ERA won’t say which.

Billing under a supervisor’s license for therapy follows rules that vary from one payer to the next. Check each contract before an associate sees a patient, because a payer can deny a claim billed under the wrong rendering provider now or recoup it later.

Tier errors can run in both directions. In 2024, Optum Recovery Services said it had paid some clinical social workers the full psychologist rate instead of 75%, then sought the difference back. Confirm every clinician’s taxonomy and payer loading once a quarter, or hand that job to provider credentialing services that track it for you.

Telehealth Place of Service and Modifier Pricing

For Medicare, POS 10 (telehealth in the patient’s home) pays the non-facility rate, and POS 02 (telehealth somewhere other than the home) pays the lower facility rate. Picking the wrong code is one of the quieter reasons telehealth therapy gets paid less than an office visit.

Modifier 95 marks real-time audio and video, and modifier 93 marks audio-only, wherever the payer requires them. Audio-only therapy reimbursement depends on the payer and, for commercial plans, on state telehealth parity law and your contract. Our POS 10 telehealth rules guide covers the payer differences.

Medicare’s home telehealth rules for behavioral health hold steady through 2027. According to the CMS Telehealth FAQ, the in-person visit requirement for mental health telehealth in the home doesn’t apply through December 31, 2027, so plan for it in 2028.

Carve-Outs, Out-of-Network Repricing, and Plan Limits

Three problems at the plan level cut therapy payments even when the claim itself is clean:

  • Claims sent to the medical carrier when a behavioral health organization manages the benefit
  • Out-of-network claims repriced to a regional allowed amount instead of a negotiated rate
  • Sessions billed past a visit limit, which pay $0 and shift the balance to the patient

Behavioral health carve-out billing trips up intake teams most. The insurance card shows one payer, but a separate managed behavioral health organization runs the mental health benefit, so the claim has to go there. Ask who administers outpatient mental health benefits on every new verification call.

An out-of-network adjudication for a clinician who should be in network often points to a loading error at the payer. Check the participation record, the effective date, and the service location before you argue about the repriced amount.

For therapy session limits, insurance plans that cap visits will pay the capped session at $0 and move the balance to the patient. Check remaining visits before each appointment, because those balances get harder to collect once a few sessions stack up.

If you’re seeing lower allowed amounts on 90837 lines and can’t tell which of these causes is behind them, our AR follow-up services team compares each paid line to your contract and flags what’s recoverable.

Short Payments That Aren’t Underpayments

Some reductions on a therapy ERA are correct, and you can’t recover them. Rule these out before you call a therapy claim underpaid, or your team will spend hours appealing money the payer never owed.

ReductionERA codeWhy it’s legitimateWhat to do
Medicare sequestrationCO-253Federal law cuts Medicare fee-for-service payments by 2%Write it off; you can’t bill the patient
Deductible, coinsurance, or copayPR-1, PR-2, PR-3The patient owes this share under the planBill the patient
Secondary payer paid less than the balanceCoordination of benefits adjustmentThe secondary pays against its own allowed amount after the primary paymentCheck the secondary’s allowed amount before disputing
Facility rate on a claim for a facility serviceLower allowed amountThe facility rate applies when the service took place in a facility settingConfirm the place of service was right
A rate cut you signedLower allowed amountThe contract amendment set the new rateRenegotiate at renewal

An EOB paid less than the allowed amount for one of these reasons doesn’t need a dispute. Don’t burn an appeal on CO-253, either. Our CO-253 sequestration adjustment guide explains why that 2% stays with you.

Mental health secondary insurance underpaid claims need the same check. A secondary plan pays against its own allowed amount, so the balance left after both payers often belongs to the patient. Count it as behavioral health revenue leakage after you’ve checked both allowed amounts.

Once you take these reductions out, any gap left between the contracted rate and the paid amount is your underpayment.

How to Find Underpaid Therapy Claims on Your ERA

To find underpaid claims, build an expected-payment table for each CPT code, payer, plan, provider type, and place of service. Then compare every paid line on your ERA, the 835 file, against that table and group the shortfalls by cause.

  1. Pull the current fee schedule for each of your top payers, plus Medicare amounts for your locality.
  2. Build the expected-allowed table by CPT code, modifier, place of service, payer, plan, and rendering taxonomy.
  3. Export three to six months of 835 data at the line level.
  4. Compare the allowed amount with the expected amount on every line, after removing the legitimate reductions.
  5. Check the billed code against the paid code to catch any 90837 paid as a 90834.
  6. Group the shortfalls by payer, CARC, clinician, and place of service.
  7. Track each clinician’s share of 90837 claims month to month against the rest of the practice.

Include every code your clinicians bill in step two: 90791, 90832, 90834, 90837, 90846, 90847, 90853, 90785, 90839, and 90840. Add modifier 95 or 93 and POS 10, 02, or 11 as separate rows, since each combination can carry its own price.

Step four carries most of the work, and it’s the same reconciliation a good payment posting and reconciliation process runs on every ERA. An ERA underpayment that gets posted without this check is hard to find later, after the claim drops off every report.

Underpaid insurance claims in mental health billing tend to cluster in a few codes and a few payers. If your system can export 835 data at the line level to a spreadsheet, you can run a basic 835 underpayment analysis for one payer in an afternoon, so start with your largest commercial contract.

CPT billedCPT paidBilledContractedAllowedCO-45VarianceLikely cause
90837-95, POS 1090834$200$140$98$102$42 shortSilent downcode
90837, POS 1190837$200$140$122$78$18 shortOld fee schedule loaded

Illustrative example. Your contracted rates will differ.

Patterns point to causes. Match what you see on the ERA with the likely cause and the place to look:

What you see on the ERALikely causeWhere to look
Lower allowed amounts on every claim from one payerOld or wrong fee schedule loadedContract and amendment dates
Short pays limited to one clinicianCredential tier or taxonomy errorRendering NPI, taxonomy, participation record
Short pays limited to telehealth linesPlace of service or modifier pricingPOS 10 versus POS 02, modifier 95 or 93
Billed 90837, paid as 90834Payer downcodeNote times and CARC 150
Out-of-network pricing for an in-network clinicianNetwork loading errorParticipation record and effective date
$0 paid with patient responsibilityVisit limit reachedBenefits and remaining visits

A CARC tells you why the payer paid a line at a different amount than you billed. Check the exact wording in the X12 CARC code list if a remark doesn’t make sense. For a 90837 underpaid through a downcode, look for CARC 150 on the line.

If building the expected-payment table is where this stalls for your team, a payer underpayment audit runs it line by line across your top payers and returns the claims you can still recover.

How to Appeal an Underpaid Therapy Claim

To appeal an underpaid claim, first decide which route it needs: a corrected claim, a payment reconsideration, a formal appeal, or a contract dispute. Then send one complete packet, with the contract rate attached, before the payer’s deadline.

ProblemRouteWhat to attach
Clerical error (NPI, place of service, modifier)Corrected claimThe corrected claim
Allowed amount below contractPayment reconsideration or disputeFee schedule page and the ERA line
Downcode or medical necessity reductionFormal appealNote with start and stop times
Network status or loading errorProvider relations or contractingParticipation record and effective date
Repeated pattern the payer won’t fixState insurance department complaint, after internal stepsClaim list, correspondence, and contract terms

Formal appeals take more work than a reconsideration, and they’re where appeals and denial management experience pays off. A payer reviewer reads the packet once, so everything the reviewer needs has to be in it the first time.

An underpayment appeal letter to an insurance company should include:

  • The claim number, member ID, date of service, and CPT code
  • The exact shortfall in dollars
  • The contract or fee schedule page showing the correct rate
  • A copy of the ERA line
  • The note with start and stop times, for time disputes
  • The specific correction you want the payer to make

Deadlines decide most of these cases. For Medicare, you have 120 days from receiving the initial determination to request a redetermination. Commercial windows come from each contract and plan, so pull the appeal language for your top payers.

Timely filing runs on its own clock. A mental health timely filing denial on a corrected claim hurts most, since the original claim was payable and your team had every document it needed to win.

Claims age past these windows when no one owns the follow-up. Mental health AR follow-up needs a named person checking every open dispute each week, or a therapy AR follow-up partner doing it. If an insurer keeps underpaying a therapist on the same code after you win, escalate the pattern through provider relations.

Parity law can back a mental health underpayment dispute if a plan applies stricter payment rules to behavioral health than to comparable medical care.

Federal enforcement of parity is unsettled. In March 2026, the federal departments told a court they won’t defend the 2024 parity rule and plan to propose replacement rules by December 31, 2026, so treat parity as a supporting argument.

How to Stop 90837 Underpayments Before They Start

Five monthly habits target each cause you control: recording start and stop times, reloading fee schedules, checking credentials and taxonomy, setting telehealth codes by payer, and running a variance report. They’re the same controls a strong behavioral health revenue cycle runs on every claim.

Use a note template with real times. Record start time, stop time, and total psychotherapy minutes, kept separate from E/M time, plus one sentence on why the session ran long. Remove any default that prints “60 minutes” on every note.

Reload fee schedules on a schedule. Update the expected-payment table every January 1 and after every contract amendment. Then check the first remits after each effective date.

Check credentials every quarter. Confirm each clinician’s rendering NPI, taxonomy, and participation status with every payer you bill, including the behavioral health organizations behind carve-outs.

Set telehealth codes by payer. Keep a single grid of POS 10 versus POS 02 and modifier 95 versus 93 for each payer, and update it when a payer changes its policy.

Run a monthly variance and utilization review. List short pays by payer, and compare each clinician’s share of 90837 claims with their own history and the rest of the practice. Look into sudden shifts, up or down, before a payer flags 90837 overutilization or sends a 90837 audit request.

A year of documented short pays also helps at renewal time. Therapist insurance rate negotiation goes better when you can show a payer which lines it underpaid and by how much, and that record gives you leverage against behavioral health underpayment in the next contract term.

What Changes for Therapy Reimbursement in 2027

For 2027, the Medicare conversion factor drops 2.31%, psychotherapy codes reach the final year of their increase in work values, Medicare home telehealth rules for behavioral health hold through December 31, 2027, and Illinois starts a rate floor for in-network mental health care.

  • Conversion factor: $33.40 falls to $32.63 for clinicians outside qualifying APMs, effective January 1, 2027.
  • Psychotherapy values: 2027 is the last year of the phase-in that began in 2024, so pull the new amounts from the CMS look-up tool.
  • Telehealth: CMS doesn’t require the in-person visit for home mental health telehealth through December 31, 2027.
  • Illinois: plans regulated by the state and issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2027, must meet a floor, set by formula, for in-network mental health and substance use disorder services.
  • Parity rules: the federal departments said they’d propose replacement parity regulations by December 31, 2026.

Lawmakers in Illinois went further on 90837 itself. Illinois Public Act 104-0446 requires covered plans to cover medically necessary 60-minute psychotherapy billed as 90837. It also bars them from imposing more onerous documentation for 90837 than for other psychotherapy codes, or auditing 90837 more often than those codes. Medicaid plans fall outside the law.

Before the first 2027 remits post, load the new Medicare amounts and any commercial amendments into your expected-payment table. Mental health payer contract rates often change on January 1, and a loading error in January can cost you a full year of psychotherapy underpayment if no one checks.

Therapy Claim Underpayment FAQs

Why are my therapy claims underpaid when the ERA shows them as paid?

The shortfall sits inside the CO-45 contractual adjustment. Your payer paid the line but allowed less than your contract rate, so the extra adjustment looks like a normal write-off.

Compare the allowed amount on each line with the contracted rate for that code, payer, and provider type. The common causes are a downcode, an outdated fee schedule, a credential tier error, or telehealth pricing.

Can insurance pay a 90837 claim at the 90834 rate?

Yes. A payer can downcode the line, price it from an outdated fee schedule, or work under a contract that pays both codes the same. In 2026, Aetna proposed paying 90837 at the 90834 rate for clinicians on the Alma platform, then dropped that part of the plan.

If your note shows 53 or more minutes of psychotherapy, appeal a 90837 paid as a 90834 with the start and stop times attached, along with the contract page that lists the 90837 rate.

Does billing 90837 trigger an audit?

Billing 90837 isn’t a violation, and plenty of sessions qualify. Payer reviews focus on documented time and on billing patterns, such as a clinician whose claims are almost all 90837 with identical note times. If a 90837 audit letter arrives, check your notes for start and stop times first.

Then send what the letter requests, and nothing extra, by its deadline. In Illinois, the law bars covered plans from auditing 90837 more often than other psychotherapy codes.

Can an insurer take back money already paid for therapy?

Yes. Commercial recoupment rights come from your contract and state law, so read the overpayment section of each agreement. For Medicare, 42 CFR 405.980 lets a contractor reopen a claim within one year for any reason and within four years for good cause.

Insurance recoupment in mental health often follows a documentation audit or a credential tier error, so a therapy insurance clawback tends to trace back to the note or the provider record.

Why does an LCSW get paid less than a psychologist for the same code?

Medicare sets payment for clinical social workers, marriage and family therapists, and mental health counselors at 75% of the clinical psychologist amount. On CY2026 national rates, that’s $125.25 for 90837 against $167.00. Commercial plans often tier by license as well. Some mental health claims underpaid for an LCSW are correct under that tier, so check the contract before you dispute.

Are out-of-network therapy claims more likely to be underpaid?

No published data compares underpayment rates for in-network and out-of-network therapy claims. Out-of-network claims do carry two extra risks. Repricing vendors can set the allowed amount from regional data instead of a negotiated rate, and a loading error at the payer can push an in-network clinician into out-of-network pricing. Check network status first, then dispute the repriced amount.

How long do I have to dispute an underpaid therapy claim?

For Medicare, you have 120 days from receiving the initial determination to request a redetermination. Commercial deadlines come from each contract and plan, and they vary, so pull the appeal language for your top payers and put each date on a calendar.

Timely filing is a separate limit for corrected claims, so a corrected claim can miss its window even while the appeal deadline is still open.

When It Makes Sense to Get Billing Help

Therapy claims underpaid by a few dollars a line don’t stand out on any single remit. Across a caseload, though, one 90837 a day paid as a 90834 adds up to $12,744 a year per clinician on CY2026 Medicare rates, and commercial contracts can run higher or lower.

If you want a second set of eyes on your remits, bring three things: your in-network and out-of-network mix, your clinicians’ license types and states, and three months of ERAs.

The team at One O Seven RCM can run a mental health billing audit from that and show you which short pays you can still recover. A therapy practice billing audit like this works the same way for a solo clinician or a large group.

About the Author

Alex Mahone

Alex Mahone is the Sales Director at One O Seven RCM, with more than 12 years of experience in the medical billing and healthcare revenue cycle management field. Through his work with healthcare providers and medical practices, he has developed a strong understanding of the day-to-day challenges involved in billing, collections, and revenue cycle operations. Alex also contributes to the One O Seven RCM blog, where he shares practical insights based on his industry experience to help healthcare professionals better understand medical billing and RCM-related topics.

Recent Blogs

Therapy Claims Underpaid? Why Practices Lose Revenue on 90837 and Similar Codes

Insurance Credentialing for Therapists: From CAQH to the First Paid Claim

In-House vs Outsourced Billing for Mental Health Group Practices: A Real Cost Model

ABA Claims Denied Despite Prior Authorization? How to Trace the Billing Failure

Cardiology RCM KPIs: How to Track A/R, Denials, and Underpayments by Procedure

How much do mental health billing services cost for a private practice? (2027 pricing guide)

Book a Consultation